Logo

Packers’ Former First-Round Pick Projected for Surprise Week 1 Benching

In a surprising projection by Bleacher Report, Green Bay Packers linebacker Quay Walker, a former first-round draft pick, is predicted to be sidelined in favor of Isaiah McDuffie for the starting lineup in Week 1 of the 2025 NFL season.

Selected 22nd overall in the 2022 NFL Draft, Walker was expected to become a cornerstone of the Packers’ defense. However, Bleacher Report forecasts that McDuffie, a sixth-round pick (220th overall) in 2021, will take his spot. This prediction is a shock, given Walker’s status as a high draft investment for Green Bay.

Why This Projection?

Several factors contribute to this bold forecast:

  • Walker’s Inconsistent Performance: Over three seasons, Walker has struggled to meet expectations. His rookie year in 2022 was marred by inconsistency and two ejections, drawing criticism from fans and analysts alike.
  • McDuffie’s Emergence: Isaiah McDuffie has shown significant improvement, particularly in defensive reliability and consistency. He is seen as a better fit for the new 4-3 defensive scheme implemented by defensive coordinator Jeff Hafley.
  • Scheme Change: The Packers’ shift to a 4-3 defense requires linebackers with strong coverage skills, and McDuffie appears to align more closely with these demands compared to Walker.

Fan Reaction

The projection isn’t entirely surprising to some Packers fans. During the previous season, certain fans called for McDuffie to replace Walker at times due to the latter’s uneven play. Still, the idea of a first-round pick being benched remains a contentious topic and is likely to spark debate.

Packers’ Roster Context

Following the 2025 free agency period and NFL Draft, the Packers did not significantly bolster their linebacker depth. One notable addition is Collin Oliver, a hybrid linebacker/edge rusher from Oklahoma State, but the team largely relies on its current roster. The departure of Eric Wilson to the Minnesota Vikings has heightened the focus on the competition between Walker and McDuffie. Meanwhile, De’Vondre Campbell remains a key figure in the defensive unit.

Implications for the Season

If Bleacher Report’s prediction holds true and Walker is benched, it would signal that the Packers are prioritizing current performance over pedigree or long-term potential. Such a move could put immense pressure on Walker to reclaim his role or risk being traded, much like Eric Stokes, another former first-round pick who was previously demoted from the starting lineup.

Comments (0)

Loading comments...

Coach Mike Tomlin Remove 3 Players for Missing Practice
Pittsburgh, PA — September 18, 2025 — Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin has made a bold disciplinary move, benching three key players—cornerback Joey Porter Jr., outside linebacker Alex Highsmith, and safety DeShon Elliott—for missing Wednesday’s practice as the team prepares for a critical Week 3 matchup against the New England Patriots. The decision comes as the Steelers, sitting at 1-1 after a 31-17 loss to the Seattle Seahawks, grapple with a rash of injuries and mounting pressure to stabilize their roster. The trio’s absence from practice on September 17 stemmed from injuries: Porter Jr. is nursing a hamstring issue, Highsmith is sidelined with a high ankle sprain, and Elliott is recovering from an MCL sprain. All three missed the Seahawks game, where Pittsburgh’s defense struggled, allowing 117 rushing yards to Kenneth Walker III, including a game-sealing touchdown. Tomlin, known for his no-nonsense approach, reportedly views their failure to attend practice, even if injury-related, as a breach of team standards during a pivotal week. “We’re in a tough spot, but accountability comes first,” Tomlin said in a press conference. “If you’re not on the field preparing with your teammates, you’re not playing. We need everyone locked in to turn this around.” The move underscores Tomlin’s emphasis on discipline as the Steelers face a Patriots team that racked up 122 rushing yards in their Week 2 win over Miami. Porter Jr., a rising star in the secondary, missed his second straight game in Week 2 due to his hamstring injury. Highsmith, a key pass rusher, suffered his ankle sprain in the first quarter against Seattle and has a history of soft tissue injuries, including a groin issue in 2024. Elliott’s MCL sprain, sustained during a tackle attempt, has kept him off the field, with a potential return targeted for Week 4. The decision to bench them has sparked debate, especially with the team already thin at key positions due to injuries to linebacker Patrick Queen (ribs) and rookie defensive tackle Derrick Harmon (knee), though both returned to practice this week. The Steelers have taken steps to bolster their roster, signing veteran linebacker Ja’Whaun Bentley and safety Jabrill Peppers to the practice squad. Bentley, who rejected a $6 million offer from the Los Angeles Chargers, could see an elevated role if Queen remains limited. Fans on X are divided, with some praising Tomlin’s tough stance—“This is the Steeler way!”—while others worry it risks further depleting an injury-ravaged defense. As Pittsburgh aims to shore up its run defense and avoid a 1-2 start in the competitive AFC North, Tomlin’s disciplinary action sends a clear message: no player is above the team’s standards. Whether this gamble galvanizes the roster or exacerbates their struggles will be evident Sunday at Gillette Stadium.

Latest Posts